dialtone wrote: ↑30 Jun 2025, 07:29
organic wrote: ↑30 Jun 2025, 02:14
dialtone wrote: ↑29 Jun 2025, 23:02
It will never not be funny to see Max fans complain about other drivers getting off easy… 2 races ago the champion, in a fit of rage, drove with purpose in another car in a move that alone would have warranted a dq and was given 10s post race and then only 3 points because 4 would have been another ban.
The most unreasonable fans in motorsport.
When have 4 penalty points been given out and why does the incident specifically warrant 4?
Thank you for the question.
https://www.fia.com/sites/default/files ... lean_0.pdf
This is the F1 Guidelines for Penalties and Points document released to the public after the Verstappen incident.
In this document you can clearly read: "Causing a collision with apparent deliberate or reckless intent" is a 10s stop and go, with 4 penalty points. So the Stewards decided after watching Max check 4+ times the position of George Russell, that the crash wasn't intentional nor reckless, while every single commentator, ex driver, current driver interviewed (or via some awkward form of an apology) admitted that it was 100% intentional.
"Collision" being rendered usefully vague there. I guess a collision could be anything from bumping tires and causing no loss of car control, to damaging bodywork, to shearing the car in half at the engine-monocoque interface. If a collision is bumping into another car without causing either car to leave the track, then Leclerc would also have befallen your FIA guidelines there, a few laps earlier in that race. "Causing a collision with no immediate and obvious sporting consequence" also yields a "reprimand/5s/10s or grid penalty and up to 3 penalty points."
Will you also castigate the stewards for not upholding that infraction by Leclerc? If Verstappen's action was truly reckless, there would have been shards of carbon fiber on the track. Yet, both George and Max continued on with the race. So you have to ask: what was the point of such a precise bump? Russell wasn't penalized for contacting Verstappen because of this year's famous steward guide rule about being ahead at the apex, so Max did some trolling in retaliation in order to make a statement about the guide. If you're ahead at the apex, you're allowed to contact the outside car, and/or run them off the track. As occurred a few times earlier in the season. Max didn't force George off ultimately, although he could have per the steward's guide, but that would have only provided more virtue signaling clickbait fuel for journalists. So, fairly well managed PR calculation there, considering it was parsed while driving between 100 and 200 mph.