Would F1 be improved by having 5 speed gearboxes again?

Post here all non technical related topics about Formula One. This includes race results, discussions, testing analysis etc. TV coverage and other personal questions should be in Off topic chat.
User avatar
dave kumar
12
Joined: 26 Feb 2008, 14:16
Location: UK

Re: Would F1 be improved by having 5 speed gearboxes again?

Post

PlatinumZealot wrote:
19 Jan 2018, 14:12
dave kumar wrote:
18 Jan 2018, 15:05
PlatinumZealot wrote:
18 Jan 2018, 03:01
Better keep it 8 speed. 5 speed is too little.
I'm interested in why 8 gears is preferable to 6, 5 or 4... or 20? What makes it the optimum number for the current regulations. It feels to me at least that if you go higher then 8 then you're heading in to CVT territory and gearing is a diminishing factor in car setup. May be that is the right way to go for the future, gears do seem a bit last century.
The single set of gear ratios rule hugely limits the usability of the same 5 ratios over the entire season!
You're quite correct but if we didn't have that restriction what would be your reasoning for choosing 8 gears over any other number or just going for a full on CVT. I'm deliberately sidestepping the cost aspects as I'd like to understand the impact on car setup for a given track of being restricted to, say 5 gears and whether it may have some benefits to the racing as outlined in my original post.

I'm not advocating rolling back the years based on some nostalgia for 5 speed gearboxes or stick shifts and manual clutches. It just occurred to me that restricting the number of gears may improve the racing by adding an extra dimension of compromise to the car setup as you will have to make greater compromises with fewer gears available. I'm getting the impression that the general opinion is that the selection of gear ratios are irrelevant to the current formula but I was hoping you guys with the technical knowledge could enlighten me as to why! For example is the power band of the hybrid power units is so broad as to make gearing irrelevant save for the final ratio?
Formerly known as senna-toleman

Tommy Cookers
617
Joined: 17 Feb 2012, 16:55

Re: Would F1 be improved by having 5 speed gearboxes again?

Post

the final drive ratio cannot be changed within the season
(apart from maybe 1 change allowed in seasons when the cars have changed)
loosely speaking the idea is that drivers need to use eg gears 1 - 6 at Monte Carlo and eg 3 - 8 at Monza

Moose
52
Joined: 03 Oct 2014, 19:41

Re: Would F1 be improved by having 5 speed gearboxes again?

Post

No - it wouldn't be improved. There's a reason the FIA intentionally designed the regulations so that the top end of the rev range wasn't used much. It means that when people get into a DRS train they still have revs available to get past rather than just bouncing off the rev limiter.

User avatar
dave kumar
12
Joined: 26 Feb 2008, 14:16
Location: UK

Re: Would F1 be improved by having 5 speed gearboxes again?

Post

Thanks guys, that helps clarify things. So we need to leave some revs at the top end of the range for overtaking (presumably drafting as well as DRS?).

Do you think that by having larger intervals between the ratios (ie fewer forward gears), that teams would be more compromised when setting the car up for a given track or are people broadly of the opinion that it wouldn't make much difference because the hybrid power units have such wide power bands?
Formerly known as senna-toleman

OO7
OO7
171
Joined: 06 Apr 2010, 17:49

Re: Would F1 be improved by having 5 speed gearboxes again?

Post

krisfx wrote:
19 Jan 2018, 15:27
marmer wrote:
18 Jan 2018, 15:24
Can we go back to a stick shift and a clutch peddle just for a change up. Really make the drivers work for a change
Because sustaining up to and above 5G over a 2 hour period while simultaneously adjusting over 30 switches and their associated sub functions, racing other cars and managing fuel,tyres and temps is easy.. #-o ](*,) :roll:

And I'm sat thinking this was a technical forum!
I believe marmer does raise a good point.
Managing the switches is fairly straight forward. The ability to aggressively up or downshift while braking and or negotiating a bend is also straight forward with contemporary semi-auto gearboxes.

marmer
1
Joined: 21 Apr 2017, 06:48

Re: Would F1 be improved by having 5 speed gearboxes again?

Post

whoever neggged me for that get a life for gods sake

User avatar
PlatinumZealot
550
Joined: 12 Jun 2008, 03:45

Re: Would F1 be improved by having 5 speed gearboxes again?

Post

marmer wrote:
19 Jan 2018, 20:01
whoever neggged me for that get a life for gods sake
Welcome to the club.
🖐️✌️☝️👀👌✍️🐎🏆🙏