Posted: 15 Mar 2006, 16:34
Heres more regarding the Ferrari barge boards thing (Malaysia 1999) from Shant fabrication:
Interviewed after the race, Ron suggested that the by-now bald tyres on the two Ferraris were illegal, and that a protest was in order - the possible penalty, disqualification.
The disqualification did come, but in a form nobody expected - illegally-sized barge boards. Whether the FIA was tipped-off remains a mystery, but what is certain is that the controversy raged long after the championship officially finished at Suzuka.
The bargeboards on the red cars were discovered to be 1 centimetre wider than was officially allowed. There seemed to be no argument - the cars were illegal, Hakkinen would be installed as the 'winner', and consequently the championship had been decided then and there.
On this last point, cynics suggested, lay the basis for the success of Ferrari's appeal. Title showdowns are always good for ratings, and particularly because Japan is a flyaway race, the viewing figures would be seriously diminished if the title was already decided. Hence, something had to be done.
That something was the re-instatement of both Ferraris, much to the chagrin of Ron Dennis. To this day, Max Mosley is absolutely adamant that Ferrari won on the basis of its appeal, and not because there was a title at stake. Ron Dennis, for his part, is equally adamant that forces beyond those of the FIA Tribunal were at work. There is one other thing that needs to be known however, and that is that Ferrari was allowed to look at its cars, even though they had verbally admitted that their car was illegal - instead, they intended to appeal on a punishment-not-fitting-the-crime basis. On this point, the rules are explicit: unless the team in question admits to the infringement in writing, the car must be impounded until the appeal is heard. Ferrari was therefore able to look at its cars, and on the evidence available, changed the basis of its appeal. The end result is, of course, history.
All in all, it was an ugly resolution to a race which had marked a rapid return to form for Ferrari, although it did prove to be a suitably contentious lead-up to the title showdown, two weeks later, in Japan. This weekend's race will be face a mammoth task if it is going to match the inaugural race for controversy, but we live in hope that it will prove to be more exciting in terms of on-track action.