Page 1 of 2
Solidworks, Help!
Posted: 21 Oct 2012, 18:45
by CottrellGP
I am new to solid works and when i export my files from sketch up it says i need to select a component, is there anyone that can help me?
Re: Solidworks, Help!
Posted: 21 Oct 2012, 19:02
by RicME85
check your mail, have sent a pm from a convo i had with astracrazy, should help
Re: Solidworks, Help!
Posted: 21 Oct 2012, 19:46
by flynfrog
i didn't think you could export files directly from sketchup to SW.
Re: Solidworks, Help!
Posted: 21 Oct 2012, 20:37
by astracrazy
yes you can
you need to get the solid inspector plug in (to make sure you have a complete water tight solid) then get the .stl exporter for sketchup. export your object/solid as an .stl. You can then import the .stl model into solidworks. you have to make sure its a solid else you'll get an error when running the solver
as far as i know thats the best way, i haven't found any other easier way
Re: Solidworks, Help!
Posted: 21 Oct 2012, 20:46
by CottrellGP
astracrazy wrote:yes you can
you need to get the solid inspector plug in (to make sure you have a complete water tight solid) then get the .stl exporter for sketchup. export your object/solid as an .stl. You can then import the .stl model into solidworks. you have to make sure its a solid else you'll get an error when running the solver
as far as i know thats the best way, i haven't found any other easier way
Ive been exporting as DWG
Re: Solidworks, Help!
Posted: 21 Oct 2012, 21:18
by astracrazy
ye i first done it like that, but it caused a lot of problems and took up a lot of time. the .stl way is much quicker and easier
Re: Solidworks, Help!
Posted: 24 Oct 2012, 19:55
by CottrellGP
Does anyone know how to change the direction of the flow trajectories?
thanks
Re: Solidworks, Help!
Posted: 25 Oct 2012, 10:22
by astracrazy

on this screen you need to select external, then check the two check boxes at the top
you'll need to select gravity and it will give you a value something like -9.88...etc (this appears once you've selected it). Make sure you change this to the vertical axis. in this image its y. Make sure the other two axis are 0

i know you can't see it, but at the top you need to select air

here is where your problem is. In this picture lets use the z axis. because you want the air flowing in the direction of your model not in the direction of the z axis arrow (see bottom left) you'll need to put -75 in the velocity direction for axis x.
(or whatever m/s your running)
hope this makes sense? give me a shout once you've done it and i'll explain setting up goals to get your downforce and drag values
i don't claim to be a pro in solidworks, this is just what i've gained from youtube videos etc.
this is a good video, you can find part 2 easily. it gives you everything you need to know about running a test. it just misses out the gravity bit
http://youtu.be/ctBA_4rkhPo
Re: Solidworks, Help!
Posted: 25 Oct 2012, 17:44
by CottrellGP
Your help has been brilliant astracrazy! ive managed to get simpe things working in solidworks, but i cant seem to get parts from sketchup, like my front work to work as it says it needs to be a component all the time, and im not sure if the solid inspector works.
Re: Solidworks, Help!
Posted: 25 Oct 2012, 18:18
by Jersey Tom
Perhaps a silly question... but if you have a proper CAD package in Solidworks, why design in Sketchup to begin with?
Re: Solidworks, Help!
Posted: 25 Oct 2012, 19:38
by astracrazy
jersey: its much easier to use and the kvrc is run in sketchup. some use solidworks for our own testing
cottrell: are you getting any red/orange circles/line when you run the solid inspector?
Re: Solidworks, Help!
Posted: 26 Oct 2012, 17:02
by RicME85
Sketchup is a lot more 'pick up and play' in its ease of use compared to Solidworks IMO.
I agree with Dan, astra you have come up good with the SW info, your pm's have helped me loads

Re: Solidworks, Help!
Posted: 26 Oct 2012, 17:16
by astracrazy
no problem guys. the only thing i can't find how to do is get the center of pressure (which is used in the kvrc runs)
did you get solid inspector working? (to both of you)
Re: Solidworks, Help!
Posted: 27 Oct 2012, 15:59
by RicME85
I did but still cant work out all the bits that need doing.
Seems there are too many issues with my rear wing so I'll just not bother trying to get it in to SW

Re: Solidworks, Help!
Posted: 29 Oct 2012, 19:19
by CottrellGP
Yes, astracrazy i have everything sorted, just annoying when you have a sketchup model with a lot of faces trying to thicken them all

. but other wise its all good except i don't think my results are right because i am not sure how to change the flow speed.