Improve the Pit Stops

Post here all non technical related topics about Formula One. This includes race results, discussions, testing analysis etc. TV coverage and other personal questions should be in Off topic chat.

Post Thu Sep 02, 2010 10:31 pm

Does any one think that the pit stops should be improved.
Here is what it needs to be improved:

1. Reduce the amount of pit crew members when the car is being serviced in the pits. I watched F1 Debrief show on Speed Channel and one of the commentators were discussing the amounts of accidents involving the car hitting the pit crew member when living the pits. They said that the amount of pit crews should be reduced from 19 (current) to 6 or 8 people. This will reduce the human traffic and incidents during pitting and post pitting and also make the pitting more interseting and fun to watch. There would be 2 people per tire change
(8 total), 2 jack men, 1 loly pop man, and 2 re-fueling (when it returns),
so that will bring a total of 13 (with refuling) and (11 without refuling).

2. Bring back the re-fuiling. F1 should improve the Re-fuiling system so that the cars could be refuled once again. The race is still boring when the cars have a full tank of fuel and the only time the race is the best is at the start and near the end when there is less fuel and the cars go faster.

3. Please no more handicaping top 10 drivers in the final qualifying session it ruins the race. the drivers should have the freedom to start as much as fuel they wish and what type of tires they wish. It is hard to know the true best time.


Let me know if enything else needs to be improved.
mkw0101
 
Joined: 14 Jun 2010

Post Thu Sep 02, 2010 10:35 pm

Bring refueling back
mep
 
Joined: 11 Oct 2003
Location: Germany

Post Thu Sep 02, 2010 10:59 pm

I guess the best way to stop pitcrew getting flattened would be to not let them out until the car they are working on is stationary in its box, and then not letting it leave until the crew have gone back into the garage.

Most crashes in the pits happen when drivers drive over their own pitrew when coming and going, right? If so, reducing the number of men would not really reduce the number of accidents, since the men are standing in an area where the cars can drive onto. It might reduce the number of people hurt in such accidents, but not the number of them.

If safety is a big driver, then wouldn't bringing refuelling back make things more dangerous? Think about all the times when drivers have gone while the fuel nozzle has been detatched from the car. This tends to drag people around and set fire to things. Definately not good

----

Irrespective of this, I'd much prefer to keep pit-crews as they are. I think it's wonderful how everyone has his own job to do, all within 4 seconds of being stationary.

Making the men do multiple jobs would mean they had to do awkward things like getting up and moving around. That'd spoil the well-oiled-machine look for me.
tommylommykins
 
Joined: 12 May 2009

Post Thu Sep 02, 2010 11:01 pm

I like number 1 but without the lollypop man to make it more challenging
Spencer
Shrek
 
Joined: 5 Jun 2009
Location: right here

Post Thu Sep 02, 2010 11:39 pm

I aggree with number 1, id make it that each car can only make it that only 8 guys can service the car, one per wheel, the jack men and two others for help where needed. As for the Lollypop man, get rid of him and let the race engineer do that from the pit wall. Or have the pit crew, but the front jack man be in the garrage before the car stops, then work begins at a pace.

As for refueling, the thing is that the rigs that were used untill last year were bulky and very costly to ship. My solution would be a simple, clear plastic container that is suspended above the garrage and comes down via total gravity fed lines. For saftey reasons id have fuel stops as stand alone fuel stops that has to last a minimum of 10 seconds. But id also do this with a standardised fuel tank of 80KG as well.

As for the handycapping, id make it that drivers cannot stop for rubber untill at minimum of 30% of the race has elapsed, and that from P11 downward has to start on the hard rubber, and cannot stop untill the 70% of the race has elapsed. But id also make it that those drivers who didnt make it into Q3 are the only ones eligible to get 5 points for fastest lap, meaning more drivers will do a Kimui in otherwords.

Pit stops should be part of the strategy, and giving the P11 and down something to aim for would improve the racing as a whole.

I think pit stops should have a full and frank discussion on, everyting from saftey (eg: wheels and car realease) to saftey car periods and how much they should play in a race strategy.
ESPImperium
 
Joined: 5 Apr 2008
Location: Glasgow, Scotland

Post Fri Sep 03, 2010 8:28 pm

The pitcrew should come in when the car is fully stopped and is safe to service it. The car should leave when all pitcrew are not near the car then the car can leave the pit.
mkw0101
 
Joined: 14 Jun 2010


Return to General chat

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: CCBot [Bot] and 9 guests