Team radio to be open this year

Post here all non technical related topics about Formula One. This includes race results, discussions, testing analysis etc. TV coverage and other personal questions should be in Off topic chat.
User avatar
WhiteBlue
92
Joined: 14 Apr 2008, 20:58
Location: WhiteBlue Country

Team radio to be open this year

Post

James Allan wrote: Some good news for F1 TV viewers
January 29, 2009 by speedmerchants
Yesterday I wrote about some things we will not be seeing on TV, today I’m posting on a couple of things which will be in the show, although I’m not sure about one of them.

Radio conversations between team and driver have been available for a few years, but the team had a button it needed to press to make the channel open to the TV director. Renault were always very good and open about this, even though it used to irritate them that the director kept playing clips of them telling Fisi to push harder. Ferrari and McLaren were useless at opening the line, and would simply open it at the end, after a victory for some stage managed gushing. This season the radios will be open all the time from every team, so you should hear some much more insightful stuff and get a feel for how the big names come across on radio in the heat of battle.

The other thing I’m not so keen on. I’m told that the teams and the FIA are seriously planning to publish the weights of the cars after qualifying. If this is true I think it is mad as it takes away from the suspense of the opening part of the race and might make teams inclined to do more or less the same thing on fuel strategy as each other, which will create more of a procession.

One of the reasons qualifying with fuel has worked was because there was the chance to go short or long and we couldn’t be absolutely sure, because there was always that margin for driver error.

Also it will devalue the pole before the race has even started if say, Kubica has achieved it by running six laps less fuel than Hamilton and Massa. We’ll all stand on the grid saying, “So what?”

I hope that this change does not come about. The new mood of openess in F1 is good, but this is one step too many for me.
Friend Allan brings us good news with the open radio channels and some twisted thoughts as we are used by him.

What the heck is good about race fuel qualifying anyway? It is a farcial, useless show compared to the real thing they used to do in the past. What people want to see is the fastest man in the fastest machine, pedal to the metal, full stop. Anything else is showboating IMHO.
Formula One's fundamental ethos is about success coming to those with the most ingenious engineering and best .............................. organization, not to those with the biggest budget. (Dave Richards)

User avatar
ISLAMATRON
0
Joined: 01 Oct 2008, 18:29

Re: Team radio to be open this year

Post

but he is right, as it is posting the fuel levels (or car weights same thing) takes away from the show and suspence of the first 3rd of the race.

But ultimatly we want the teams to have to declare their intended race fuel b4 qualifying and have Q3 be an all out low fuel dash for the pole.

natef1
natef1
0
Joined: 30 Oct 2008, 13:15

Re: Team radio to be open this year

Post

ISLAMATRON wrote:but he is right, as it is posting the fuel levels (or car weights same thing) takes away from the show and suspence of the first 3rd of the race.
ISLAMATRON wrote:But ultimatly we want the teams to have to declare their intended race fuel b4 qualifying.
Contradiction much?

Radios, fantastic. Fuel, if qualifying stays the same way it is now, then no, don't reveal it.

User avatar
ISLAMATRON
0
Joined: 01 Oct 2008, 18:29

Re: Team radio to be open this year

Post

Miss something much? Like the second part of that sentance... but I did forget to include "declare their race fuel to the FIA" not to everybody.