Post here all non technical related topics about Formula One. This includes race results, discussions, testing analysis etc. TV coverage and other personal questions should be in Off topic chat.
Bizarre that Mercedes did not make more efforts to find a driver at least at the level of Button or Rosberg. For example Alonso or Ricciardo were available for 2019, perhaps they would perform worse than Button or Rosberg compared to Hamilton after all, but Mercedes did not even trial these drivers to find out!
I suspect Hamilton would have Vetoed Alonso and possibly Ricciardo too.
I suspect Hamilton would not have approved of Alonso for a team mate, but not because he would not be sure of trouncing him, but because of politics in the team and press. However, I am also fairly sure that had he complained to toto about it he would have been told 'tough luck, live with it'
I disagree with what you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it-
Voltaire, or several other claimants.
I think the criticism towards Bottas is a bit harsh. If Hamilton is considered the greatest driver to ever drive, then BOT isn't as bad as people think.
Yet Bottas is demonstrably not as good as Button or Rosberg compared to Hamilton. That's the problem.
Bizarre that Mercedes did not make more efforts to find a driver at least at the level of Button or Rosberg. For example Alonso or Ricciardo were available for 2019, perhaps they would perform worse than Button or Rosberg compared to Hamilton after all, but Mercedes did not even trial these drivers to find out!
What is so bizarre about that? In fact, I think that after 2016, it's absolutely logical that MB didn't want another driver like Rosberg.
They wanted a Barrichello. And they found one.
What is so bizarre about that? In fact, I think that after 2016, it's absolutely logical that MB didn't want another driver like Rosberg.
They wanted a Barrichello. And they found one.
Been saying this for the last 2 years! To be fair to the haters though, this season he hasn’t been close enough to play that role. Coming 2nd to Ham all the time will annoy the haters but barely scraping points might be an issue for MB.
I suspect Hamilton would not have approved of Alonso for a team mate, but not because he would not be sure of trouncing him, but because of politics in the team and press. However, I am also fairly sure that had he complained to toto about it he would have been told 'tough luck, live with it'
Last time I've checked Toto Wolff was the team principal in Mercedes, not Hamilton. Why would Hamilton have to accept a team mate? He may express his opinion but the decision should not be up to him.
I'm pretty sure this isn't going to happen, but for arguments sake. Let's say Mercedes doesn't want to pit Russel against Hamilton and risk either a 2007 ALO-HAM rivalry or a 2017 ALO-VAN soul-crushing.
How about Gasly?
He pulls out good results, and well, by now he should have realized both that Red Bull will never take him back, and also, that he might not be as good as Hamilton and Verstappen.
Ocon staying at Renault. What does that mean for Mercedes. That Hamilton will stay a bit longer with Russell as his team mate? Don't see Russel and Bottas for the years to come.
I think the criticism towards Bottas is a bit harsh. If Hamilton is considered the greatest driver to ever drive, then BOT isn't as bad as people think.
Yet Bottas is demonstrably not as good as Button or Rosberg compared to Hamilton. That's the problem.
Bizarre that Mercedes did not make more efforts to find a driver at least at the level of Button or Rosberg. For example Alonso or Ricciardo were available for 2019, perhaps they would perform worse than Button or Rosberg compared to Hamilton after all, but Mercedes did not even trial these drivers to find out!
I'm not Russell's manager or his Mum.
I don't care about his personal, best interest. I'm talking about the Team, and the huge value of increasing above the sum of the individual parts.
Last edited by Zynerji on Thu Jun 17, 2021 2:17 pm, edited 1 time in total.
I suspect Hamilton would not have approved of Alonso for a team mate, but not because he would not be sure of trouncing him, but because of politics in the team and press. However, I am also fairly sure that had he complained to toto about it he would have been told 'tough luck, live with it'
Last time I've checked Toto Wolff was the team principal in Mercedes, not Hamilton. Why would Hamilton have to accept a team mate? He may express his opinion but the decision should not be up to him.
Is that not what I said?
I disagree with what you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it-
Voltaire, or several other claimants.
Verstappen is the biggest threat to Mercedes by a country mile. Signing Verstappen would kill two birds with one stone; finding a solution to the Hamilton problem, and distancing themselves from the competition.
It won't happen though, even if Verstappen's supposed "exit clause" permits it.
In reality, its probably going to be Bottas for another year.
