German Gp 2009 - Nürburgring

For ease of use, there is one thread per grand prix where you can discuss everything during that specific GP weekend. You can find these threads here.
dave34m
dave34m
-1
Joined: 04 Aug 2008, 10:46

Re: German Gp 2009 - Nürburgring

Post

The funny thing is that Webber tried to say that he couldn't see either car in his mirrors.
Both of the cars were in front of him when he hit them, lol

User avatar
ISLAMATRON
0
Joined: 01 Oct 2008, 18:29

Re: German Gp 2009 - Nürburgring

Post

andartop wrote:How would my "tifosi bias" affect my view on an incident involving a Red Bull and a McLaren car, I cannot see. How can a couple of pics prove whether Lewis would or would not have made the corner, I cannot see either.
Have to admit though that you are right, I shouldn't have used the word "crash" but "contact". It seemed to me that LH closed in on Mark Webber which resulted in his rear right tire "contacting" with Webber's front wing. Maybe my Ferrari biased vision gets poor when the red cars are further back. A video of the incident might be helpful.
Your anti Hamilton bias is a clear as your pro Ferrari bias, and I am pretty sure they are connected. Regardless, if you watch the video you will see that Webber reacted to the contact with RB with a movement back to his left. And if you use the pit lane exit divider line as a reference Webber was moving to the left at the same time HAmilton was moving to the right when the contact occurred. Webber clearly had space to his right so he could have easily avoided the contact... still I would not say he was "at fault"... just a racing incident which a couple of inches would have negated.

Moreover if you continue to watch the video you will clearly see a puff of tire lockup smoke from HAmilton before RB starts to brake himself, and they were going relatively the same speed and Hamilton was on the preferred racing line... he would have clearly made the corner.

User avatar
ISLAMATRON
0
Joined: 01 Oct 2008, 18:29

Re: German Gp 2009 - Nürburgring

Post

dave34m wrote:The funny thing is that Webber tried to say that he couldn't see either car in his mirrors.
Both of the cars were in front of him when he hit them, lol
Which would clearly show why he couldnt see them in his mirrors... maybe too much mirror driving by Webber... but he made up for it.

Edit, he was actually ahead of RB when he turned into him... Webber right rear into RB's left sidepod.

User avatar
ringo
232
Joined: 29 Mar 2009, 10:57

Re: German Gp 2009 - Nürburgring

Post

Michiba wrote:what's up with Vettel now? He's not the same exhuberant personality he was last year. Looks like he was sulking during the post race interview, and couldn't even crack a smile when Massa was joking with him.

I'm not trying to 'hate' on him, but last year, they were marketing him as being different to all the other prima donna drivers in the paddock, but seems like he's changed his attitude now. Has he become an Alonso?
Vettel is only nice when he wins. This is not a good mind set, sometimes i thinks it clouds his driving when someone is going faster than him or is ahead of him.
I noticed that he could of went on pole if he was not so twitchy today, it seems like he was frustrated that webber and hamilton were faster most of the weekend at his home GP.

expect some tension between the 2 as redbull decides who will be champ.
For Sure!!

andartop
andartop
14
Joined: 08 Jun 2008, 22:01
Location: London, UK

Re: German Gp 2009 - Nürburgring

Post

ISLAMATRON wrote: Your anti Hamilton bias is a clear as your pro Ferrari bias, and I am pretty sure they are connected. Regardless, if you watch the video you will see that Webber reacted to the contact with RB with a movement back to his left. And if you use the pit lane exit divider line as a reference Webber was moving to the left at the same time HAmilton was moving to the right when the contact occurred. Webber clearly had space to his right so he could have easily avoided the contact... still I would not say he was "at fault"... just a racing incident which a couple of inches would have negated.

Moreover if you continue to watch the video you will clearly see a puff of tire lockup smoke from HAmilton before RB starts to brake himself, and they were going relatively the same speed and Hamilton was on the preferred racing line... he would have clearly made the corner.

If you could post a link to that video it would be clear for all to see. A puff of tire lockup smoke is by no means an indication of more effective braking..And if Hamilton was moving to the right doesn't that mean that he as well had space to his left to avoid the contact?
The most merciful thing in the world, I think, is the inability of the human mind to correlate all its contents. H.P.Lovecraft

vasia
vasia
0
Joined: 15 Apr 2008, 22:22

Re: German Gp 2009 - Nürburgring

Post

Ah, so it was Sutil's fault in fact. I retract my previous statements then.

User avatar
ISLAMATRON
0
Joined: 01 Oct 2008, 18:29

Re: German Gp 2009 - Nürburgring

Post

andartop wrote:If you could post a link to that video it would be clear for all to see. A puff of tire lockup smoke is by no means an indication of more effective braking..And if Hamilton was moving to the right doesn't that mean that he as well had space to his left to avoid the contact?
Dont have a video to post but I am commenting from the normal Fox(delayed) broadcast... so it should be clear for anyone who DVR or taped it to see. I did not say that his lockup smoke was an indication of more effective braking, but an indication that he was braking earlier than RB. I you think he does not brake very well than that is up to you. And yes he had space to move to the left just as Webber had space to move to his right... but the main difference was that Lewis was clearly all but a couple inches ahead of Webber, so Webber had a much better view of the situation. But like a said, merely a racing incident.

User avatar
ISLAMATRON
0
Joined: 01 Oct 2008, 18:29

Re: German Gp 2009 - Nürburgring

Post

vasia wrote:Ah, so it was Sutil's fault in fact. I retract my previous statements then.
Sutil's fault why?

User avatar
djos
113
Joined: 19 May 2006, 06:09
Location: Melbourne, Australia

Re: German Gp 2009 - Nürburgring

Post

ringo wrote:
Michiba wrote:what's up with Vettel now? He's not the same exhuberant personality he was last year. Looks like he was sulking during the post race interview, and couldn't even crack a smile when Massa was joking with him.

I'm not trying to 'hate' on him, but last year, they were marketing him as being different to all the other prima donna drivers in the paddock, but seems like he's changed his attitude now. Has he become an Alonso?
Vettel is only nice when he wins. This is not a good mind set, sometimes i thinks it clouds his driving when someone is going faster than him or is ahead of him.
I noticed that he could of went on pole if he was not so twitchy today, it seems like he was frustrated that webber and hamilton were faster most of the weekend at his home GP.

expect some tension between the 2 as redbull decides who will be champ.
Did you two even watch the post race Press conference or when Vettel got out of his Car shook Webbo's hand and then gave him a congratulatory hug?

Vettel congratulated Webber sincerely and was most definately not half hearted in the press conference either!
"In downforce we trust"

Shrek
Shrek
0
Joined: 05 Jun 2009, 02:11
Location: right here

Re: German Gp 2009 - Nürburgring

Post

Is it just me or does Kimi always have bad luck at least when he's not winning.
Spencer

Michiba
Michiba
4
Joined: 28 Apr 2008, 08:58

Re: German Gp 2009 - Nürburgring

Post

yes, I did see that djos, but I also saw the post race interview, which I think was quite telling.

Sure, no one likes to lose or come second, but I made a reference to last year, when he won. Everyone was saying what a nice guy he is etc. I just think that if that was true, he wouldn't act like he did during the interview.

I don't necessarily see it as a bad thing, just that he's not as sporting as I was made to believe. Having said that, if he keeps it up (his attitude), I think he can become the next schumacher for sure. You don't win races by thinking that it's ok to come 2nd.

Saribro
Saribro
6
Joined: 28 Jul 2006, 00:34

Re: German Gp 2009 - Nürburgring

Post

vasia wrote:Ah, so it was Sutil's fault in fact. I retract my previous statements then.
Well, "fault" may be a bit of an overstatement. It may have been a somewhat ambitious move for being on 10sec fresh tyres. I suppose the punishment fit the "crime".

User avatar
paused
0
Joined: 30 Mar 2009, 01:16

Re: German Gp 2009 - Nürburgring

Post

=D> =D> =D> =D> =D> =D> =D> =D>

Congratulations to Mark. Definitely one of the most underrated drivers on the grid. It certainly shows that given the right car, Mark can mix it at the front.

How wretched would he have felt when he got the penalty. Talk about thinking you will get the win for sure only to think it was lost in an instant. No doubt a bit of luck did finally go his way with the gaps and traffic but you have to congratulate Mark and RBR for kepping the ship steady to get the job done.

IMO the move with Rubens was a bit too aggresive. He really only need to squeeze him rather than belt him but then again probabky no worse that at least 10 moves from Lewis in 07/08.

I am very much looking forward to the balance of the season. It would only take 1 DNF from Button to really make the championship exciting.

User avatar
paused
0
Joined: 30 Mar 2009, 01:16

Re: German Gp 2009 - Nürburgring

Post

A bit off topic, but is anyone else willing to bet that RBR will win the Constructor's Championship? Momentum counts for a lot in the biz and to me a 19.5 deficit doesn't look too hard to overcome. A 1-2 finish will guarantee a min 7 point advantage (over 3rd / 4th). So as long as RBR have a good result in Hungary then the chances of realing in Brawn look quite good.

User avatar
djos
113
Joined: 19 May 2006, 06:09
Location: Melbourne, Australia

Re: German Gp 2009 - Nürburgring

Post

Michiba wrote:yes, I did see that djos, but I also saw the post race interview, which I think was quite telling.

Sure, no one likes to lose or come second, but I made a reference to last year, when he won. Everyone was saying what a nice guy he is etc. I just think that if that was true, he wouldn't act like he did during the interview.

I don't necessarily see it as a bad thing, just that he's not as sporting as I was made to believe. Having said that, if he keeps it up (his attitude), I think he can become the next schumacher for sure. You don't win races by thinking that it's ok to come 2nd.
Personally I thought these comments from Vettel were extreemly Sporting:
“Congratulations to Mark,” Vettel underlined. “He was unbeatable today – he was quicker than all of us, so he totally deserved to win. I'm very happy with the result, and in the end it was a good recovery. It was quite a bad start and I had all the KERS cars around me – I got passed by both the McLarens and even Felipe. It was quite difficult to start fourth and go into the first corner in eighth or something.

“I then struggled a lot with the soft tyres in the first stint and was in a lot of traffic. I could have gone quicker, but there was no way to pass Felipe, as he always used the special button when I was quite close. Therefore I was lucky to have the right strategy, as that pulled us back to second position but Felipe didn't stop pushing, so it was hard until the end of the race.

“We had to fight, but it's another one-two finish for the team and I'm happy. I'd be lying if I said I'm very pleased with second, as of course I wanted to win, but yesterday Mark did a better job and that's why today he totally deserves the win – it's a good fight between us, so I'm looking forward to the next races.”

Vettel: Webber was 'unbeatable' – and totally deserved to win
"In downforce we trust"