Seanspeed wrote:dialtone wrote: ↑05 Aug 2025, 19:30
This is not the right thread for speculation.
Russell is the only one that talked about raising tire pressure. No reliable source talked about it. That’s a totally made up fact until a reliable source confirms that it happened, until then it didn’t happen and the data supports that it didn’t happen, and I've already posted enough about this in the appropriate thread for this topic so at some point people should engage in the conversation there and counter the arguments.
"It's ok for me to pass off my speculation as fact, but not others". You dont KNOW that the plank wear thing isn't a problem, but you've said you know this anyways. This is also passing off your own speculation as fact. Ferrari are themselves being super cagey about all this, so all that people can do is speculate.
Your posts are usually good, but this one isn't going down well for me. I also dont understand why this thread wouldn't be a place to discuss potential technical issues with the car. Vanja himself is regularly making speculation posts about what he thinks is going on, but you've never complained about it. If we can have speculative discussions about the technical aspects of the positives of the car, why not the negatives?
I think this thread is about the car specifically. Pics of it and the engineering around it. And facts most of all. Speculation belongs in the other thread. So if people want to put content here that explains the engineering behind the plank wear issue, I think that would be appropriate, but discussion of the behavior of the team during a race belongs in the team thread. This is how I understand the content policy of these threads at least.
When I wrote “I know” I was being provocative because the crowd claiming it was plank wear did it with no information at all, and that is frustrating in an engineering forum and in this thread in particular. Sorry about the post not being good, but Russell was speculating by his own admission, not sure how saying so classifies as speculation.
EDIT: to be clear, I never said don't speculate to anyone here, I said go to the other thread to do it if no data or reasoning or technical content is provided. And as I wrote, the news was speculation until confirmed by reliable source.